No, the problem I have with them is that I move around too much in bed and everything gets tangled up. Leakage is too big a risk, just as it is during the day- if somehow the bag leaks or the hose comes off, a pair of shoes is ruined; add to that the odor of spilled urine that would be hours old would be a tell-tale sign. It's just not worth the risk for anyone even with diminished mobility. For someone in a wheelchair, it's a better option, so long as they don't overfill it.