Hard to say as everyone has different 1)body types and shapes, 2)leakage volumes, 3)comfort tolerances, 4)lifestyles and mobility, etc.
I can only speak for myself- average middle age guy body type, bit of a belly, at this point constant slow leakage with surges here and there (like stress incontinence) that probably averages a cup or so an hour, more or less depending on hydration and activity.
I work full time, have a social life and don't want to / can't stop any of that stuff.
I can do pads for a short time but they tend to fill up pretty fast so usually I don't. Also hitting dead center of the pad is sometimes problematic. Plus I don't really have any regular underwear left to use them with.
Pullups are great, and my main thing. I have the luxury of one person bathrooms at work which helps. Easy to take off shoes and pants. I like McKesson ultra and ... strangely, Always discreet underwear for women. I am make but these work amazing and are pretty cheap. It is really embarrassing though at home.
At night I can get away mostly with north shore supreme lite briefs which are plastic backed. i like the blue ones, no one but me can tell if they are wet or dry. I like that. When I need positive security, these are what I wear. I have a subscription. Bed stays dry 90% of the time unless I sleep in until 10AM
I tried washable things but am just too busy to do that much laundry and always end up with horrible ammonia smells so pretty much gave up on those. Not sure they save much in terms of water and electricity useage anyway. Plus not as comfortable when wet.
I am always experimenting to see what works. My ideal pull up type product (for men) is something like depends real Fit, with twice the padding up front, and leak guards, as well as considerably softer fabric.
Good luck in the hunt!